Dear A Girls Guide to Cars:
I need a new car. I want a DVD system for my son and seating for more than five people, also. Should I look at a minivan or an SUV, and which one is best? Which do you drive?
Thanks, Mary H., Brooklyn, NY
I drive an SUV with a third row and I chose if for many of the reasons you might choose a minivan. My advice is to consider the similarities and differences between the two and then decide which is right for you.
Minivans are great when you regularly have a lot of people or stuff to carry. The third row is easily accessible and when you don’t need it, the seats fold down for extra cargo space. They also have sliding center doors which typically can be operated by a button on the key fob or from the driver’s seat, so once everyone is in you can close the doors for them. Last, minivans have deep cargo wells in the back, so there’s an extra 10 or so cubic feet of storage. Great for leaving beach chairs or snow gear in your car all season.
Chrysler Pacifica might give you the most for your money, and it has a plug-in EV/hybrid version. The Honda Odyssey was newly redesigned for 2018 and the middle seat in the center row pops out creating captains chairs when you need them. Toyota Sienna is the most popular, has maybe the best combination of features and is available with all wheel drive (it’s the only minivan that has it) and reclining seats with foot rests. My husband loves the Nissan Quest, but it’s the biggest one of all—feels more like a van than a mini van.
If you’re going to be driving in the country a lot, especially in winter, AWD should be a requirement. You don’t want to slide off the road or get stuck in an icy driveway. You might want to think about a full sized SUV with a third row: Ford Explorer (the best selling full size SUV in the country), Honda Pilot (this sets the standard for space and reliability), VW Atlas (one of the most popular new SUVs), Chevy Tahoe (pricey but awesome), Toyota Highlander (which comes in a hybrid version and gets 28MPG!), or Nissan Pathfinder (all-around fun). All have a third row and have pretty good storage. Tahoe lets you choose AWD, 2WD or 4WD, which increases your fuel economy but gives you the capability when you need it. SUV fuel economy is about the same as a mini van, so don’t focus too much on that.
If you only need the third row occasionally, perhaps consider a crossover or SUV with a smaller third row. Mid size or compact SUVs—Kia Sorento, Hyundai Santa Fe, Dodge Journey, VW Tiguan and Nissan Rogue– will be easier to park in the city and offer that extra seating when you need it.
Most of these SUVs and minivans offer an entertainment system option, built in WiFi and Bluetooth that everyone can connect to. The bonus of an entertainment system is that often back seat passengers get extra apps such as navigation so they can see how far it is to your destination, games or entertainment channels. Some don’t though, and many customers are deciding to invest in tablets and WiFi packages rather than a built in system.
For young kids or families that take a lot of road trips, the built in system may be a benefit, especially with wireless headphones that let passengers listen in– or not. But for families with older kids who may have their own games and entertainment channels already loaded on a tablet or phone, simply going with the WiFi might be enough–and save you $2,000 on the price of the car.
Hope this helps you to decide the best option for your family,
A Girls Guide to Cars